How much does a Storey Lake Airbnb actually make? It depends on the property type, but the range is wide. A 2-bedroom condo brings in around $31,000 a year. A 9-bedroom estate clears $123,000.
We manage over 100 vacation rentals in Kissimmee and across Orlando’s resort communities, including Storey Lake. These numbers come from our portfolio, not projections. Here’s what the income picture looks like right now.
$78K
Avg 5BR Gross Revenue
77-83%
Managed Occupancy
~$450K
Median Sale Price
-5%
YoY Price Change
What Storey Lake Properties Earn
| Property Type | Bedrooms | Annual Gross Revenue | Occupancy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Condos | 2-3 BR | $31,000 – $47,000 | 77-83% |
| Townhomes | 4-5 BR | $42,000 – $66,000 | 77-83% |
| Single-Family | 5-6 BR | $65,000 – $90,000 | 77-83% |
| Estate Homes | 7-9 BR | $80,000 – $123,000 | 77-83% |
For context, the Kissimmee market median sits at $52,000 per year with 69% occupancy. Professionally managed Storey Lake properties run 8 to 14 points higher on occupancy. That gap is where the extra $15,000 to $30,000 comes from.
The 5-6 bedroom single-family home is the sweet spot for Storey Lake rental income. High enough revenue to cover expenses, low enough purchase price to maintain reasonable returns.
When the Money Comes In
Summer runs June through August at 82-90% occupancy with peak nightly rates. Spring break (March and April) follows close at 78-85%. Holiday season books 72-82% but commands the highest ADR of the year.
Shoulder months are September through November and January through February. Occupancy drops to 58-68%. This is where most owners lose revenue and where dynamic pricing makes the biggest difference.
Since Epic Universe opened in May 2025, shoulder-season dips have gotten smaller. Families are booking longer trips and bigger houses to fit Disney, Universal, and Epic Universe into one vacation.
What It Actually Costs to Own Here
Gross revenue numbers look great until you subtract expenses. Here’s what a 5-bedroom pool home at Storey Lake actually costs to run per year.
| Expense Category | Annual Cost | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| HOA + CDD | $7,400 | $430/mo HOA + $2,282 CDD |
| Property Taxes | $12,600 | 1.8% of $700K assessed value |
| Insurance | $3,200 | Vacation rental policy required |
| Property Management | $14,000 | ~18% of gross revenue |
| Utilities & Maintenance | $8,400 | Electric, water, internet, pool, repairs |
| Licensing & Supplies | $1,700 | DBPR, county STR license, consumables |
| Total Annual Expenses | ~$47,300 |
On a 5-bedroom grossing $78,000, that leaves roughly $30,700 in net operating income. Self-managing owners save the $14,000 PM fee but trade 15-20 hours per week in guest communication, turnovers, and maintenance coordination.
Tax note: Osceola County does NOT auto-collect the 6% Tourist Development Tax through Airbnb or Vrbo. You or your property manager must collect it from guests and remit it to the Osceola County Tax Collector monthly. Late penalties start at 10%. For the full breakdown, check our Storey Lake Airbnb Guide.
Why Some Storey Lake Owners Earn Double
The gap between $65,000 and $90,000 on the same floorplan comes down to three things.
Dynamic pricing during shoulder months. When occupancy drops to 58-68%, owners who price aggressively fill the calendar. Flat-rate pricing leaves 30 to 40 nights empty between September and February. That’s $4,000 to $8,000 left on the table.
Professional photography and listing optimization. Click-through rate drives Airbnb’s search algorithm. Better photos mean more clicks, more clicks mean higher placement, higher placement means more bookings at higher rates. It compounds.
Themed rooms and game rooms. In the Orlando market, a Disney-themed bedroom adds $20 to $40 per night. A solid game room adds $25 to $75. On 250 booked nights, even a $25/night premium is $6,250 in extra revenue per year.
2026 Market
Is It Still Worth Buying at Storey Lake?
Property values are down about 5% year over year. Median sale price sits around $450,000. Average days on market: 150. It’s a buyer’s market.
For investors, that means better entry prices and more room to negotiate. A 5-bedroom pool home that sold for $750,000 in 2022 might close at $680,000 today. At $78,000 gross revenue, the yield math is better now than it was two years ago.
With Epic Universe driving longer stays and bigger group bookings, Storey Lake’s location 4.2 miles from Disney and 14 miles from Epic Universe puts it in a strong position. For investors watching this market, the entry math is the best it’s been in three years.
We did a full Storey Lake vs Windsor Hills comparison if you’re weighing communities.
Want a Rental Projection for Your Storey Lake Property?
Get a free income estimate from Mike Chen and the FunStay Florida team. We manage Storey Lake rentals daily and can show you exactly where your property stands. See our Storey Lake property management services.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much can you earn on Airbnb at Storey Lake?
Annual gross revenue ranges from $31,000 for a 2-bedroom condo to $123,000 for a 9-bedroom estate. The most common property type, a 5-6 bedroom single-family home, grosses $65,000 to $90,000 per year with professional management.
What are the annual expenses for a Storey Lake vacation rental?
A 5-bedroom pool home costs roughly $47,000 per year to operate. That includes HOA and CDD fees ($7,400), property taxes ($12,600), insurance ($3,200), property management (~$14,000), utilities and maintenance ($8,400), and licensing ($1,700). Net operating income typically runs $28,000 to $43,000 depending on gross revenue.
What occupancy rate do Storey Lake Airbnbs get?
Professionally managed Storey Lake properties run 77-83% annual occupancy. That compares to a 69% median across the broader Kissimmee vacation rental market. Summer peaks hit 82-90%, while shoulder months (September through November) dip to 58-68%.
Is Storey Lake a good investment in 2026?
Property values are down about 5% year over year, making it a buyer’s market with a median sale price around $450,000 and 150 days on market. Lower entry prices mean better yields on rental income. Epic Universe has also strengthened demand for vacation homes near the Orlando parks.
What makes some Storey Lake rentals earn more than others?
The biggest factors are dynamic pricing during shoulder months, professional photography that drives click-through rates on Airbnb, and themed bedrooms or game rooms that command $20-$75 per night in rate premiums. The difference between a $65,000 and $90,000 year on the same floorplan usually comes down to these three things.
