$450K
Median Sale Price
183
Homes Sold (12 Mo)
96%
List-to-Sell Ratio
146
Avg Days on Market
Storey Lake home values range from about $265,000 for a 2-bedroom condo to over $1.5 million for a 9-bedroom estate, with a Storey Lake median home price near $450,000. But in an STR-zoned resort community, the number a buyer will actually pay depends on something most appraisal sites miss entirely: documented rental income.
We manage Storey Lake vacation rentals at FunStay Florida. Below is the actual 2026 market data, broken down by property type, subdivision, and the factors that move your Storey Lake vacation home worth up or down.
Storey Lake Home Values by Property Type
How much your Storey Lake vacation home is worth depends first on what you own. Bedroom count, property type, and whether the home has a private pool create wide price gaps within the same community.
| Property Type | Bedrooms | Sale Price Range | Annual STR Revenue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Condos | 2-3 BR | $265K – $415K | $31K – $47K |
| Townhomes | 4-5 BR | $430K – $550K | $42K – $66K |
| Single-Family (pool) | 5-6 BR | $580K – $800K | $65K – $90K |
| Estates | 7-10 BR | $800K – $1.5M+ | $90K – $123K |
The revenue column matters because investor buyers don’t just compare your home to recent sales. They calculate value from what the property earns. A 4-bedroom townhome generating $55,000 in documented annual revenue is worth more than an identical unit with no rental history.
Pool homes in the 5-6 bedroom range hit the sweet spot for investor demand. The floor plan and bedroom count directly drive how much revenue a property can generate, which feeds back into what buyers will pay.
What Storey Lake Homes Are Actually Selling For
Over the past 12 months, 183 Storey Lake homes have changed hands. Here is how the numbers break down:
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Average asking price | $514,509 |
| Average selling price | $493,588 |
| List-to-sell ratio | 96% |
| Average days on market | 146 days |
| Active inventory | 194 homes |
Sellers are taking roughly 4% haircuts from ask to close. That $21,000 gap between average asking and average selling is consistent with a buyer’s market. Properties also sit for 146 days on average, about 2.5 times the national average of 58 days.
Recent closed sales at Storey Lake:
| Property | Sale Price | Date |
|---|---|---|
| 4 BR / 3 BA townhouse (Simile St) | $435,000 | May 2026 |
| 4 BR / 3 BA townhouse (Windermere Ave) | $435,000 | Jul 2026 |
| 5 BR / 4 BA townhouse (Windermere Ave) | $495,000 | Oct 2025 |
| 4 BR / 3 BA townhouse (Windermere Ave) | $430,000 | Nov 2025 |
| 3 BR / 2 BA condo (Clock Tower Dr) | $309,000 | Nov 2025 |
Price Differences by Subdivision
Storey Lake is not one neighborhood. Storey Lake property values vary significantly by subdivision:
| Subdivision | Median Sale Price | Year Built |
|---|---|---|
| Cove at Storey Lake | $580,000 | 2020-2022 |
| Reflections at Storey Lake | ~$455,000 | 2018-2020 |
| Storey Lake Phases 1-3 | $420K – $500K | 2015-2019 |
Newer construction in the Cove commands a premium because of updated floor plans, better finishes, and energy efficiency. But the older phases sometimes offer higher net yields since the purchase price is lower while rental rates are similar.
How Rental Income Changes What Your Home Is Worth
Traditional appraisals compare your Storey Lake home value to recent sales of similar properties. That method works for residential neighborhoods. In an STR community where every buyer is an investor, your Storey Lake rental income value drives the final number, not just comps.
Two identical 5-bedroom townhomes at Storey Lake can sell for very different prices. One with 18 months of documented revenue, $55,000 gross, 78% occupancy, and strong guest reviews will attract income-approach buyers who value it at $500,000 or more. The other, with no rental track record, sells on comps alone at $450,000.
That $50,000 gap is the premium for proven cash flow. And it works in reverse: a property with poor reviews, low occupancy, or inconsistent revenue will sell below comps because buyers price in the risk of underperformance.
If you plan to sell your vacation home at Storey Lake, the most valuable thing you can do right now is build your rental documentation. Monthly revenue, occupancy rate, average daily rate, and guest review scores. Buyers want 12 or more months of verifiable data. Projections mean nothing without proof behind them.
Ownership Costs Buyers Factor Into Value
Every investor buyer backs into their offer from net yield. They start with gross revenue, then subtract every recurring cost. Higher costs mean your Storey Lake vacation home is worth less to the buyer making the offer.
| Cost Category | Monthly Range | Annual Range |
|---|---|---|
| HOA Fees | $286 – $545 | $3,432 – $6,540 |
| CDD Assessments | Varies by phase | Varies |
| Property Taxes | $496 – $1,327 | $5,955 – $15,929 |
| Insurance (HO-6 + Umbrella) | $150 – $350 | $1,800 – $4,200 |
| Electricity | $150 – $300 | $1,800 – $3,600 |
| Total Recurring Costs | $1,082 – $2,522+ | $12,987 – $30,269+ |
On a townhome selling for $450,000 with $55,000 in gross annual revenue and roughly $20,000 in recurring costs, the net revenue is around $35,000. That puts the net yield at about 7.8%. Buyers in the Storey Lake real estate market are targeting 6-8% net yields on stabilized properties.
Property taxes are public record through the Osceola County Property Appraiser. If you don’t know your exact numbers, start there. Assessed values, tax history, and building details are all searchable by address.
To work backward from your target sale price and see whether the math works for buyers, run the numbers through a full ROI calculator walkthrough with your actual costs.
Storey Lake Market Trends in 2026
The headline for the Storey Lake real estate market in 2026: property values are down but rental revenue is holding.
The Storey Lake median home price has dropped 8 to 11% year-over-year, landing around $450,000 for the trailing 12 months. Price per square foot is down roughly 11% to $181. Active inventory sits at 194 homes, and properties average 146 days on market (the national average is 58).
The price decline reflects broader Orlando market softening and elevated inventory. Lennar built Storey Lake between 2015 and 2023, and additional phases are planned (358 single-family homes, 212 townhomes, and 297 condos). More supply is coming.
But rental revenue has not declined at the same rate. Professionally managed Storey Lake Airbnb properties are maintaining 70-83% occupancy, and nightly rates are holding near pre-2026 levels. That means the gap between what comps say your Storey Lake home value should be and what income-approach buyers will pay is actually widening.
For sellers, this creates an opportunity. If your property generates strong, documented revenue, your Storey Lake rental income value supports a premium over declining comp-based prices. If it doesn’t, you are exposed to the full market downturn.
Frequently Asked Questions
Get Your Storey Lake Property Valued
Whether you want to maximize rental income or sell your vacation home at Storey Lake with income-backed pricing, we can help. We manage Storey Lake vacation rentals and know what these properties are worth from the revenue side, not just the comp side.
